An excellent scene in one of my favourite movies, “The Princess Bride” involves one guy continually using the word “inconceivable” … and another guy eventually saying to him, “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”
But the word we’re going to discuss isn’t that one… the word of the day is “freedom”.
Americans seem to think they have a monopoly on “freedom”. Hey guys… up here – we’re free too, you know. In fact, of the 206 recognized sovereign nations, the vast majority are also free.
On the list of countries that are not so free, you’ll find places like China, North Korea, Cuba, Syria, Venezuela… places that are perpetually in the news, often for the wrong reasons, and that’s why perhaps we never hear about the rest of the world. Uruguay? Bulgaria? Mongolia? They all have their own problems to navigate, like any other sovereign nation… but their people are free, by whatever definition you want to apply. But perhaps since the U.S. isn’t meddling in their affairs, you never hear about them.
Somewhere along the line, the meaning of “freedom” has lost its way, especially by those who’ve never experienced the lack thereof. Anyone who’s been born and lived all their lives in the U.S. (and Canada), no matter how old they are, has never lived under a government that didn’t offer them freedom. Yet even today, more than half the world’s population lives without the basic freedoms we all take for granted.
It’s hard to put it in terms for people who’ve never experienced it, so let’s compare it to something relatable.
I’m old enough to remember well when smoking was ubiquitous. Ten-hour airplane flights so full of smoke you couldn’t even see the screen of the movie playing 20 rows ahead. Tiny no-smoking areas in restaurants, if any. Everyone smoked back then, whether directly or second-hand.
When smoking bans were proposed, there was a huge uprising… and the word freedom was thrown around a lot. It’s my right, it’s my freedom, all the bullshit arguments you can imagine. And it goes back to what I said yesterday; nobody wants to infringe on anyone’s rights. You want to smoke at home? As long as the smoke doesn’t bleed into someone else’s space, go right ahead. You want to smoke alone in the middle of nowhere, go right ahead. You want to smoke in a crowded boardroom because it relaxes you and helps you gather your thoughts? Too bad. Because what you feel you’re entitled to is not as important as other people’s health and comfort. Go outside.
Yes, you will be inconvenienced and perhaps feel offended… but everything about that situation is up to you. You are free to make those choices. And if you still want to scream about rights and freedoms, perhaps a little history lesson… or perhaps, just a present-day history lesson… of people who can’t leave where they are, can’t say what they want to say, aren’t free to participate in the religion or partnership they wish to pursue. *That* is a lack of freedom. Not you having to step outside to smoke where it doesn’t bother anyone else. There’s no issue of freedom there. That’s just part of living in a civilized society that’s decided that the harm inflicted by cigarette smoke is not something anyone has the right to impose on someone else.
Similarly, can we just cut the crap with masks and freedom? It’s not the end of your world to act responsibly for the benefit of us all. You’re not being deprived of some fundamental right, unless you feel that putting others at risk is something to which you’re entitled. This is temporary and this is necessary.
I’m well aware that there are people who’ll read this and still not get it, tossing aside the science and common sense. So just get this…. shut the hell up already with claiming someone is infringing on your rights. Nobody is making you wear a mask when it’s not called for. Smoke at home. Cough and sneeze at home to your heart’s content. But while there’s a virus going around that threatens us all, simply do your part. If you’re around other people, do what’s asked… or, just don’t be around other people.
See how easy that is? You *are* free – free to do whatever you want as long as it doesn’t interfere with someone else’s basic rights. I have the right not to inhale your cigarette smoke. I have the right not to inhale your Covid-19. I would hope for most people, this is pretty clear… though I’m also very clear that for a lot of people, this is… inconceivable.
Nailed it ???????? ???? ????
Hi Horatio, I hope you can clarify something for me. A lot of people talk about how well BC is doing, but with a third of the population of Ontario we are more or less a third of the cases, so even though it is less people aren’t we doing (more of less) equally badly by population? And BC has a 1.7% increase in cases as compared to 1.3% for Ontario, so our case load is increasing slightly faster, is that correct?
I’m so grateful for you compiling these numbers, it feels like a place of science and sanity.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WxdaU9AsnU
Wear your dam mask
Great hook!
I was attacked today ( the person saying it’s his “right” to NOT wear a mask) and his comment was ” My rights don’t end where your fear begins. F.O. and stay at home if your (yes spelled wrong) scared.”
To take your smoking analogy a bit further :
In 1980 I was flying on a company 737 Tuktoyaktuk to Calgary with a team of Dutch sailors one of which was an ex Dutch royal navy version of a Seal. As tall as I was twice as wide and nicotine addicted. He lit up on the plane home and the stewardess came by and told him to put it out, there was stubborn resistance. The stewardess had authority to ban him from the company plane and enforce all of the company policy against flying on a Dome petroleum flight ever again and more. What ever she said wasnt going to be obeyed. The only way he kept his job and wasnt dumped at the wrong end of the Yellowknife runway, was I had a very quick word with his Captain and asked him to tell the sailor to comply with a very quick YES MAAM. Which he did.
Bonnie Henry’s gentle advice may be approaching that point now, there is a hammer in her velvet glove.