I’m writing this while watching today’s provincial update with Dr. Henry and Minister Dix. I used to watch this every day, but not so much anymore. What’s interesting is that, recent details aside, it’s the same old thing… and why wouldn’t it be? The message hasn’t really changed. Or, at least, shouldn’t. This is a perpetual Public Service Announcement. Act responsibly, be kind, do the right thing, etc. To a great extent, I think they realize they’re preaching to the choir. There’s not a single person watching this today thinking, “Gee – that’s a good idea. Maybe I’ll start doing that.”
One thing to clarify… hearing them claim that 41.5% of eligible B.C. residents have received at least one dose of vaccine. The key word there is “eligible”… because if you remove that word, the correct number – the number I’ve been tracking – is 36.5%… and the reason is that, at some point, the eligibility list, which at present does not include anyone under the age of 18, will change… and that denominator will change, and the percentage will drop. But for now, according to what they’re saying, it’s 41.5%… and that number should grow to 100% well-before July 1st. It won’t, because, as we know, not everyone who’s eligible for a vaccine will want one… but it’s a good target. It would be achievable, but it won’t happen… not because of lack of supply or logistical challenges. It’ll simply be because of vaccine hesitancy and denial.
What happens after that is as good a guess as any. Will that mean we’ve reached herd immunity? Probably not. The answer last year might have been yes, but these new variants are more contagious, meaning a higher Rø… meaning a higher percentage threshold of immunity is needed. The hard-set 15% of naysayers were never going to have their minds changed. But it’s in the next 25% where you’d find that tipping point… the “maybe” crowd. Somewhere in the 60% to 85% range, where herd immunity exists.
But also, reaching herd immunity here in B.C. might not mean much when we’re such an international hub of travel. We’re 30km from the U.S., which will never reach herd immunity. We have flights coming and going from every high-risk area, present or future.
I am all in favour of vaccine passports and anyone screaming about freedom and human rights might be forgetting the convenient fact that nobody has the human right or freedom to impose disease upon anyone else. Keep your mask-less face and anti-vaxx attitude far away from those who want no part of it. If you think you’re free to not wear a mask or get a vaccine, you must to agree that those who disagree with you should be free to not want you around. I fully support a “Covid-free passport” requirement for entering this province… and notwithstanding the optimism with respect to locally getting things under control sooner than later… we are not an island, and we will never be truly isolated from this virus.
But that doesn’t mean things can never get back to normal. They can… and they will. It might just take longer and it might look a little different. One way or the other, though… we are racing towards a finish line.
While I lean toward agreeing in principle on a vaccine passport of some sort, I’m very concerned about the practicalities of it. What do you do about people who cannot get the vaccine, due to allergies, or other underlying immune system issues? What about people who have an honestly held religious belief (akin to JW’s not allowing blood transfusions)? I think there’s an enormous can of worms there with no easy answers.
I just watched the first horse race (Thoroughbred) run in Canada – Hastings!
I’m still dumbfounded by all the news articles of places opening up for international travel by the summer, or the UK government allowing a 5,000 person maskless rave at last weekend… all feels much too soon. Surely India is a perfect example of opening up too much, too quickly.. At least give those worldwide who want to be fully vaccinated (even if it only amounts to 60%) a chance to do so before opening the floodgates (which is several months away really)
The end of the beginning and the beginning of the end are both points on a curve (logarithmic or otherwise) that have not been connected so what passes for a finish line could be more of a Möbius strip, to torture the metaphor further.
That I might get my second AZ shot in June is the most optimistic opinion you’ve thrown around in some time, Horatio.
Yes to the Covid free/ vax passport!
NY and NYC is aiming to fully reopen in 2 weeks (a month too soon if you ask me). I wish there were a discussion of what precautions should persist going forward. I especially regret how good ventilation has never been part of the discussion. Regardless, May 2021 is better than May 2020, and we’re going to need to live with heightened risk because of our failures to deal with the virus on its terms.
Horatio Kemeny I also agree that a vaccine passport is a great idea. As well, it is really nothing new…in 2000 I had to have a special Yellow Fever vaccine “card” /proof of vaccination to be able to enter a specific country (I was travelling a lot then so don’t remember if it was Brazil or Kenya or India). You literally could not enter the country without this proof of vaccine card…and the result…we got to travel there…and we didn’t get yellow fever! 😁
It’s hard to help people understand what freedom means and what loss of freedom (or risk of such) means if they don’t “just get it”. You’d hope that folks understand the concept of a “slippery slope”. You’d hope that someone’s fear of “this” or “that” doesn’t reduce some one else’s right to be free. I could go on.
Then you’re also dismayed when some of your smarter friends don’t see the near impossibility of a workable “vaccine passport” even disregarding the “grossness” of such. The concept is designed to fail and to prolong chaos. For example, does every new “variant” require a new passport? Do they expire every x-months as vaccines wear off? Is it a paper passport or electronic and how will the minimum wage employee at the gate/terminal/door/etc be expected to know every version of the passport? And on and on.
Horrible idea for mankind but great idea if prolonging chaos is (still) the objective….
You can also subscribe to HK’s great posts by e-mail https://kemeny.ca/subscribe/