Today marks one month since I posted my first little chart, with an accompanying short little paragraph explaining it. What’s the date today? March 58th? Seems that way.
Since then, everything has grown… the numbers have grown, the lines on the graphs have grown, and the volume of my little paragraph has as well. It seems to be dealing with a lot more than just numbers, doesn’t it… so… on that note…
Today’s update at 11am from Dr. Henry and Mr. Dix was a thorough presentation explaining where we’re at and where we’re going. The slides of that presentation are available on the BCCDC website, but I’ll give you the summary — we’re doing really well around here, well enough that we can stop comparing the Italy track… we’re not following it… and, looking at the numbers and charts below, haven’t been for a while. And recognizing that we may be seeing a plateau, on its way to a decline — cautious optimism — of many key numbers. New infections, hospitalizations, ICU cases… everything trending in the right direction. We are seeing lower numbers for new infections, even with enhanced testing. For now. We will see next week if the long weekend changed anything.
And it’s key to note that this success has largely been a result of the measures put in place, the timing of those measures, and our compliance with them. And now is not the time to stop. “It’s working” is a lot different than “It worked”. We are still a work in process, and those social/physical-distancing ways-of-life will be around for a while.
Capacity to handle patients is below 50%, and it’d be ideal to keep it there. The absolute certain end to this is a vaccine, and things will be different until then, but it doesn’t mean we’re stuck in our homes forever. The plan for opening things up with a methodical, well-thought-out strategy is in the works, but the last thing we want to do is open things up too quickly. That can drastically change things, and it can happen quickly. One interesting slide, #34, showed the results of dynamic modelling, testing different outcomes given the degree of compliance of social/physical distancing. Short answer — if we keep doing what we’re doing, very good. If we don’t, there are varying degrees of what would happen. Worst case scenario: we all take to the streets today…. In about 10 days, the near vertical growth in cases would quickly overrun our medical infrastructure. That model also implies that a little loosening wouldn’t have a drastically bad effect… but to what extent and how… again, as you can see on that slide, if you hit a tipping point, it’s hard to come back from it. And speaking of that scenario…
There was a story on CNN yesterday with a headline that read “The social-distancing deniers have arrived”. Before clicking on the story, I imagined the picture that’d accompany it… it would be a group of people protesting. I imagined bushy beards, hunting caps, guns, American flags, Trump signs and no masks. I was a little wrong about the masks… a couple of guys had them; the rest, bang on. Oh, and not just guns… assault rifles.
I have a great idea. Get Barack Obama, Joe Biden and Nancy Pelosi to hold a press conference. Throw Bernie in there too. And there, they announce in angry, loud, unified voices… that social distancing is a terrible idea. That this lockdown is ridiculous. “President Trump!”, they should demand, while dramatically ripping their masks off their faces, “End this nonsense! Open every business! Get everyone out on the streets! Now! We demand you open this country, fully… RIGHT NOW!”
It might actually work.
Democrats say Zig, Republicans say Zag. Republicans say Ding, Democrats say Dong. It doesn’t even matter what Zig/Zag or Ding/Dong mean… nobody knows. Nobody cares. We are right, they are wrong. You are with us or you are against us.
Around here, we’ve pretty-much forgotten who’s in power. Premier John Horgan (NDP, if you need reminding) is not around much. I may not agree with everything he has to say, but he and I have something in common; an understanding of what leads to success… a concept that has served me tremendously well all of my life: Surround yourself with excellent people, keep them around, and let them do their thing. Two of those people these days are, of course, Adrian Dix (NDP) and Dr. Bonnie Henry (who knows and who cares). Political affiliations are pretty irrelevant at the moment.
Actually, John Horgan hasn’t been completely M.I.A… he holds a press conference once a week or so and answers questions. There are other issues facing the province, and while I’m unclear what he does all day, some of it has to do with dealing with other provincial issues, and of course, there are many. They haven’t gone away. And some of it is planning how to open up this province (beyond private liquor store hours), hopefully sooner than later, in a way that works and isn’t at odds with the big picture being laid out by Adrian Dix and Dr. Henry. Indeed, he’s letting them run the most important issue of the day, and he’s staying out of the way. It’s working really well, something even the most ardent NDP bashers would grudgingly have to admit. There will be a time and place for partisan politics, and I look forward to it because it’ll mean that things are back to normal.
In fact, the closest thing to partisan politics we’ve had recently was about all of this… Liberal leader Andrew Wilkinson serving up a little softball… “Hey, John Horgan, where are you?” The premier probably could’ve swung at that and hit it over the fence, but he let it go by and watched it dribble to the backstop. Andrew Wilkinson’s question was actually a little more pointed… like, shouldn’t the premier of the province be out in front of the cameras, telling us what’s going on, giving us updates and hope and encouragement, like a real leader… etc. And the answer is simply… no… he shouldn’t. The British Columbian leadership and response to this pandemic has a face (two of them), and it doesn’t need a third.
But behind closed doors, I have no doubt that if one of those two gentlemen needed something from the other — personally, publicly, privately, politically… they’d be listening to each other and talking and working together. If there was ever a time for political partisanship to take a back seat, it’s now. Everyone… from the top on down, needs to be pulling in the same direction. We, around here, are very fortunate.
But just a little south of here… well, that pulling looks like this: it’s a tug-of-war… one side of the rope is 500 trillion little virus balls, all pulling together. The other side is a mixed bag of people… men, women… some are wearing red shirts, some are wearing blue shirts. Some are pulling in the right direction. Some are pretending to pull but are barely holding the rope. Some are pulling sideways. Others are pushing the rope into the ground. One guy is twisting the rope… clockwise… while someone else is twisting it the other way. A couple of people have little hacksaws and are quietly trying to cut the rope without anyone noticing.
It is so incredibly sad and frustrating to watch this slow but inevitable trainwreck. You can’t look away, and wish you could do something… because solutions to the dysfunction exist… but they seem to be well-beyond the reach of the very people tasked to manage it. It shouldn’t be this convoluted. The reasonable voices do exist, of course, but they are drowned out in a sea of irrational, national insanity.
View Original Post and All Comments on Facebook
Thanks for your posts. Your rigour is particularly appreciated.
Thank you again Horatio. We’re all feeling “cautiously optimistic” now and as an “ardent NDP brasher,” I am NOT grudgingly agreeing that Adrain Dix and dr Bonnie are doing a great job on all fronts.
And now the next challenge is to get back to work, or more people will die from poverty-related causes as well as neglect (I personally know of one woman who had chest pains for a week and self diagnosed with “anxiety” and therefore did not go to the hospital, and passed away from a heart attack two days ago).
Next up: finding out the “real” number of how widespread the infection is.
For example, Stanford antibody testing shows Covid-19 to have infected 40,000-80,000 people in Santa Clara County, CA while only 1,094 have been reported to be infected. If true, then Covid-19 is much more widespread than thought. And death rates significantly lower.
buff.ly/2z9ISTO
I am of the opinion that we must keep our border closed for as long as we possible can. It pains me greatly to say that because most of my favorite places and people are in America. But we have to do it.
Just today, PMJT announced that it would stay closed until May 21 — an extension of 1 month to the original closure. Again, I hate to say it, but unless we see a miraculous turnaround south of the border, I think it needs to be more like November.
Keep ’em coming Horatio! Your paragraphs may have grown over these 58 days of March, but you continue to find entertaining and thought provoking things to write about.
We are so lucky to have the team we do. I don’t vote NDP, but I agree with your assessment completely. The Premier is doing the right thing staying off the stage, and Adrian Dix is showing an immense amount of leadership and character. His summary today before taking questions was heartfelt and he did not once use the word ‘I’. As far as Dr Henry is concerned, we all know how amazing she is.
My final comment will be that crisis does not build character, it reveals it. In this sense we have the great fortune of having many people of great character in key roles in B.C.. We all owe them our full support. IMHO.
Great read again.
Your zig zag, nailed it!
Excellent read as usual. Based on what is happening (or not happening) below the border, I have to agree that we should keep the border closed as long as possible. Thank you.
A great read and an intelligent, thought provoking voice amidst the chaos (except for Dr. Bonnie, of course).
Thank you – again! Another informative and enjoyable read. Have a good weekend!
I occasionally have diverticulitis flare up. My doc puts on 10 days of antibiotics and no alcohol. After two days the pain is gone but I have to finished the remedy. It’s the same with covid, we can’t throw over the distancing the moment the numbers go down.
Great job pls keep it up very appreciated
Your posts get better everyday Horatio Kemeny!!
“We all need keep pulling in the same direction” Perfect! Thank you.
I heard a great analogy- when you jump out of a plane, you don’t say, this parachute has really slowed me down, I’m going to take it off!
Well said and thanks for continuing to post Horatio. I enjoy the read and look forward to the next one. It is truly appreciated.
The slide deck Horatio Kemeny mentions is here, very interesting! https://news.gov.bc.ca/files/COVID19_Update_Modelling-DIGITAL.pdf
Thank you once again. Very much appreciated. Take care.
I appreciate your analysis and the daily graphs, Horatio. I just can’t help wondering if someday, someone will compare the number of people who die from stress-related and depression-related illnesses from losing their businesses due to the economic costs of these decisions with the number of people the virus claims and come to a very different conclusion than our leaders? No one is talking about those deaths right now but they will be very relevant in the months and years to come… No one has a crystal ball and 20/20 hindsight is a bitch… I just hope someone is factoring the mental and emotional costs of an economic shutdown into the decision making…
Today would have been a great time to announce the lessening of the mandatory lock down in BC. We need to hear from the Premier (and perhaps the Finance Minister) about a plan to emerge from this and we need an economic plan. We have clearly been spared from much of a health toll, and this comment isn’t meant to question the pain of those mourning the 72 dead (median age 86), but the economy is shattered, we are almost in a state of martial law, over 11,000 important surgeries have been postponed and school kids have lost part of their education. There will never be a “perfect” time to start to reopen things, but our numbers are so good yet our province and our citizens are suffering and the health risk doesn’t justify this IMO.
We are not “out of the woods” yet and if the masses congregate again (without following protocol and this only works with 100% compliance) we fall into the same shitstorm we are in and Dr Henry will have to shut the city down again…we have to stay the course (whether it was the right course or not…but we’re on it) and it looks good but as Horatio mentioned the numbers after the Easter weekend will tell a huge story as to where we are at….although I am just another frustrated bystander weighing in on a situation that we all just wish would go away…..but it won’t until we stay the course
Something going on here????